Buyer inquiry
DEAL STRUCTURE

Asset sale vs. share sale: what buyers should ask

Understand the practical differences between buying business assets and buying company shares, and the questions to take to your Ontario advisers.

First, establish what is being sold

The same operating business can be offered through different transaction structures. In an asset purchase, the agreement identifies the assets being acquired and any liabilities the buyer agrees to assume. In a share purchase, the buyer acquires shares of the corporation that owns and operates the business.

A share purchase leaves the corporation in place, including its history and obligations. An asset purchase can offer more choice over the purchase perimeter, but it is not an automatic shield against every liability. Have a lawyer evaluate the actual business and agreement.

In an asset deal, make the schedule specific

Avoid relying on a broad phrase such as “everything needed to operate.” Identify the equipment, inventory, brand rights, website, customer contracts and other items that are intended to transfer. Confirm who owns them and whether they are financed, leased or subject to third-party rights.

  • What is excluded, such as cash, receivables or particular equipment?
  • How will usable inventory be counted and priced at closing?
  • Which contracts, permits, software accounts and lease rights need consent or new arrangements?
  • How will employee arrangements and outstanding customer commitments be handled?

In a share deal, examine the company’s history

Because you acquire an interest in the existing corporation, diligence should look beyond the assets you can see. Ask advisers to investigate tax filings, debt, guarantees, employment obligations, litigation and other potential liabilities.

Do not assume that every commercial relationship continues unchanged. Review change-of-control provisions in leases, financing agreements, franchises and key customer or supplier contracts. Identify any consents that must be obtained before closing.

Compare the complete economics

An identical headline price can produce different outcomes under different structures. Ask your accountant to compare acquisition costs, tax treatment, financing and the cash the business will need after closing.

The CRA explains that asset purchases can require an allocation of price among assets, inventory and goodwill. Certain business acquisitions may qualify for a joint GST/HST election, subject to conditions. A share purchase is generally not subject to GST/HST. Do not assume an exemption or election applies without transaction-specific advice.

Bring these questions to your advisers

Ask your lawyer and accountant to explain the proposed structure together, using the same purchase assumptions. Get a clear list of unresolved risks before negotiating price and protections.

  • What exactly am I acquiring, and what remains with the seller?
  • Which historical or ongoing obligations could affect me after closing?
  • What approvals, releases and registrations must be addressed?
  • How will debt, cash, working capital and purchase-price adjustments be treated?
  • What protections are proposed if the seller’s disclosures prove inaccurate?

Choose the structure for the transaction

There is no universally better structure. The right approach depends on the company, the buyer, the seller and the risks identified during diligence. This overview is general information, not legal or tax advice.